Come on, Humble Pie live at the Fillmore was alright. Your dead on about Beck, Bogart & Appice live...had always heard Carmine was good, but when I heard him live I was inspired to seek him out and take lessons. However on recordings, it just didn't happen. I do remember Carmine drumming and singing (yeah, was Beck gonna do it?) "I'm So Proud" and really digging it. Who originally did that tune anyway? Also saw Tony Sales sing it when Tin Machine played the Campus Club and thought he nailed it. Plus brother Hunt on drums...the original R&R swing drummer (along with Dino Danelli I guess)...and you know, where would Carnival Cruiseline commercials be without Soupy's sons?